RE: allegies in soy
- To: "'Shane.Morris'" <Shane.Morris@ul.ie>,"'Roberto Verzola'" <firstname.lastname@example.org>
- Subject: RE: allegies in soy
- From: Dorothy Bowers <email@example.com>
- Date: Mon, 29 May 2000 10:33:53 +1000
- Cc: "'firstname.lastname@example.org'" <email@example.com>,"'Herve.LEMEUR@math.u-psud.fr'" <Herve.LEMEUR@math.u-psud.fr>
- Encoding: 103 TEXT
- Organization: ASEHA Qld
- Resent-From: firstname.lastname@example.org
Soya is a common classical allergen. Sometimes people with soy allergy
also cross react to similar substances and these are now common in use in
commercially produced food products. Some reports indicate that some
component of soya is in use in around 60% of processed foods and this may
well account for an increase in soya allergy if indeed this is happening.
It is difficult to get figures on food allergy, they are at best a
From: Shane.Morris [SMTP:Shane.Morris@ul.ie]
Sent: Monday, May 29, 2000 4:49 AM
To: 'Roberto Verzola'
Cc: 'email@example.com'; 'Herve.LEMEUR@math.u-psud.fr'
Subject: RE: allegies in soy
I got the York report at the time and basically the report and press
was for a new testing kit for allergies that the York lab had developed.
50% increase was in a study of I think 50 or 20 people who were tested in
1997. In 1997, 10 people had tested positive for soya allergies and in then
1998 15 tested positive in 1999 - whey hay - a 50% increase!!. The tests
where done on people with allergies already. (many with multiple
complaints). The stats are extremely weak and it essentially was a ploy by
the private company to gain press for their new kits.
After speaking at length with Mr. Graham at the time I got Kevin O'Sullivan
in the Irish Times to follow it up and the enclosed is what he found.
remember at the time the British Press were going bananas over GM!!!
The Irish Times 19th of March, 1999
...Controversy over indications of increased sensitivity of people to soya
has led the director of York Nutritional Laboratory in Britain to claim he
was misquoted in the British press. He had not linked the finding to GM
soya. Mr John Graham, who runs a food allergy company, told The Irish Times
it had simply noted "soya had crept into the top 10 foods associated with
chronic illness alongside some beans, grains and fruits".
While this might be due to increased consumption of modified soya, it could
equally be due to people consuming more soya of any kind, he
From: Roberto Verzola[SMTP:firstname.lastname@example.org]
Sent: 27 May 2000 7:17
Subject: Re: allegies in soy
>I have a sheet of paper relating an article in the Daily Express
>Mark Townsend (12 march 99) relating this study.
>Does any one have a more serious bibliography than teh NLp web
>An explanation of the lack of this report on the web site of the
York Lab ?
>(could be that there have been pressions on the lab not to
publicize this study
>or anything else ?).
This is probably the item you are referring to, as cited in the
GEDebate document I compile (version 1.0 to be issued in a week or
so...). Perhaps somebody can call up John Graham if he indeed talked
to Mark Townsend of the UK Daily Express.
- A study by the York Nutritional Laboratory, Europe's leading
specialists on food sensitivity, found that health complaints caused
by soya - the ingredient most associated with GM foods - have
increased by 50% in 1998. Researchers said their findings provide
evidence that GE food could have a tangible, harmful impact on the
human body. It is the first time in 17 years of testing that soya
crept into the laboratory's top 10 foods to cause an allergic
in consumers. John Graham, spokesman for the York laboratory, said:
"We believe this raises serious new questions about the safety of GM
foods because it is impossible to guarantee that the soya used in
tests was GM-free." (See: UK Daily Express, 12 March 1999)
The address for any administrative command like unsubscribe,
subscribe or help is:
The searchable WWW list archive is available at