GENTECH archive


Official data reveals GM crop risks

INDEPENDENT (London) June 16

Official data reveals GM crop risks

By Paul Waugh, Political Correspondent

THE GOVERNMENT will be forced into an embarrassing retreat on 
genetically modified crops today when its own research concludes that 
there is a "real risk" of contamination of other plants.

The Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food will publish a 
long-awaited report that will produce evidence of "transgenic 
pollution" from GM crops to neighbouring fields. The report, 
commissioned by Maff from the highly respected John Innes Centre, 
represents the most convincing research to date modified plants can 

Organic farmers have complained bitterly that their crops are at risk 
of contamination from pollen carried by the wind or by bees.

Ministers will announce an overhaul of guidelines issued to the 
biotechnology industry on safe planting distances from GM crops.

The Government will have "no option" but to increase the distances, 
currently set at 200 metres, ministerial sources have told The 

Maff will invite organic groups and environmentalists, as well as 
biotech firms involved in farm-scale trials across the country, into 
talks to reset the guidelines in the light of the research.

The farm-scale plantings are covered by voluntary guidelines issued by

the Supply Chain Initiative on Modified Agricultural Crops (Scimac), a

body that regulates the industry.

Pressure on the Government will increase this week when the Soil 
Association issues strict new guidelines on planting distances to its 
own organic farmers. The Association will tell its members that it 
intends to withdraw its certification if regular checks on crops find 
evidence of cross-contamination.

Patrick Holden, director of the Soil Association, gave a cautious 
welcome last night to the suggestion that ministers were preparing to 
revise the guidelines. "We are pleased that the Government is prepared

to have an open mind. If they want to increase the distances, we are 
very happy to talk to them," he said. "It's not too late to stop 
genetic pollution, but the Government has so far shown a massive 
abdication of responsibility on the issue and left us to police this. 
That has to change."

One organic farmer who had taken part in the farm-scale GM trials 
decided to burn the crops after the Soil Association threatened to 
withdraw certification. His organic beans had been just six metres 
away from GM crops.

The Government was yesterday forced on to the defensive when it 
emerged that there had been more than 100 meetings between ministries 
and biotech firms since it took power in 1997.

The John Innes Centre in Norwich is Europe's leading academic 
establishment examining GM foods. Its report accepts the premise that 
pollen from GM crops will be spread long distances by the wind and 
insects. Its results represent the first official backing for an 
earlier study by the National Pollen Research Unit on the threat of GM

pollen and seeds contaminating organic farms many miles away.

Research by the Soil Association earlier this year showed that more 
than 80 per cent of rape seed pollen is carried by bees and bees can 
travel more than three miles. Wind can transport it by much further.

Both Michael Meacher, the Environment minister, and Elliot Morley, the

Countryside minister, are understood to be in favour of giving greater

support to organic farmers.

Tony Blair has repeatedly warned against "media hysteria" over the 
issue, but ministers unveiled new advisory bodies on GM last month in 
an attempt to calm public fears about the technology.

The Government will rule out as impractical calls for a six-mile 
"buffer zone" around every GM trial, but the organic lobby insists 
that it wants the Department for the Environment, Transport and the 
Regions to warn all organic farmers within the distance before any 
licence for trials is granted.

The John Innes report is understood to have found that one per cent of

organic plants in any field could become GM hybrids because of the 
pollen spread. It concludes that contamination by either seed or 
pollen cannot be "entirely eliminated".

The Soil Association's tough certification procedures mean that scores

of farmers could be put out of business if they fail to clear 
themselves as GM-free.

One senior government adviser said last night: "If this research shows

that there is a risk, then ministers will have to respond positively 
to it."


To subscribe, write to
                               *  The Activist  *
 This is not about the world that we inherited from our forefathers,
     It is about the world we have borrowed from our children !!