GENTECH archive


Re: reply to Nina and to Ligotti, archive 1187


I don't think the airplane example fits in here. When I fly in an airplane I am
willing to take the risk because I have no other faster option of reaching
Adelaide, for instance. But why should I eat GE soya when it offers me nothing
more than non-GE soya ? Why should I take the risk of eating something which
has not been adequately tested for "business reasons"? And where is the crisis
on the food front that I have no other option but to depend only on genetic

Devinder Sharma

Rick Roush wrote:

> >Not true, Mr. Roush! You could grow your transgenic crops in your own
> >personal garden.....Nina
> Perhaps I could do all of the things that Nina suggests.  But then she
> would deny the benefits of transgenic crops to so many others.  I am sorry
> that Nina is paranoid about her tofu, but since there is already certified
> GMO free soy milk and baby food, it should only be a matter of time until
> someone meets her needs. In fact, I am surprised that there is not already
> an organic tofu.
> And about risks we choose:
> Ligotti, Maurizio's example was perhaps not the best.  How about airplanes?
> Airplanes fall down, sometimes killing people on the ground, and you have
> little choice in when or where they fly.  Never mind the noise! Airplanes
> are also increasing in numbers. Will you also seek to ban airplanes?
> The remark about strapping someone on the front of the car is either an
> illegal threat or just plain childish, especially the part about getting
> someone else to do it.
> Rick
> <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
> The address for any administrative command like unsubscribe,
> subscribe or help is:
> The searchable WWW list archive is available at