middle east menu -sunday pm
- To: "unlikely.suspects":;
- Subject: middle east menu -sunday pm
- From: MichaelP <papadop@PEAK.ORG>
- Date: Sun, 15 Nov 1998 18:06:05 -0800 (PST)
- Content-Type: TEXT/PLAIN; charset=US-ASCII
- Resent-From: email@example.com
- Resent-Message-ID: <"U1iJVD.A.NHG.7i4T2"@bakunix.free.de>
- Resent-Sender: firstname.lastname@example.org
At first reading this london Sunday Times item seems a little nutty to me.
But that newspaper is not noted for being idiotically/ideologically flak
even tho' it's very establishment-oriente. It published and stood by
Vanunu's info about Israel's nuclear bomb plant, and his subsequent
kidnap, trial and solitary confinement.
And, as with nuclear production, the technique of genetic manipulation
can't be kept hidden, and it can be practised for any purpose. The hope is
that GM ought to be held back, and its output of new species restricted
as a precaution.
But on careful reading the story seems both plausible and likely true.
They are NOT saying that the biological weapon exists, just that it's
being worked on. I happen to think the basic premise is flawed -
targetting persons by ethnic origin is not going to injure "some Arabs"
carrying distinctive genes without also injuring "some Jews" carrying the
Our hero: Iraqis applaud their leader but yesterday he capitulated to
allow the weapons inspections to continue
Photograph: Jockel Finck
Israel planning 'ethnic' bomb as Saddam caves in
by Uzi Mahnaimi
and Marie Colvin
ISRAEL is working on a biological weapon that would harm Arabs but not
Jews, according to Israeli military and western intelligence sources.
The weapon, targeting victims by ethnic origin, is seen as Israel's
response to Iraq's threat of chemical and biological attacks.
Yesterday Saddam Hussein, the Iraqi leader, backed away from the brink
of war and agreed to resume co-operation with the inspection teams
seeking his suspected chemical and biological weapons plants.
Kofi Annan, the United Nation secretary-general, said he believed Iraq
had met UN requirements. As Britain and America stood by to bomb
Saddam, however, Tony Blair's office said compliance must be
The White House, which is threatening Iraq with the biggest onslaught
since the Gulf war, said President Bill Clinton's advisers were
assessing whether Iraq's offer was adequate. The Pentagon is ready to
bomb within days.
Last week Downing Street warned Labour MPs that Saddam could be only
weeks away from completing the construction of offensive biological
weapons mounted on Scud missiles. Israel was hit by Scuds during the
Gulf war and fears it would be the prime target.
In developing their "ethno-bomb", Israeli scientists are trying to
exploit medical advances by identifying distinctive genes carried by
some Arabs, then create a genetically modified bacterium or virus.
The intention is to use the ability of viruses and certain bacteria to
alter the DNA inside their host's living cells. The scientists are
trying to engineer deadly micro-organisms that attack only those
bearing the distinctive genes.
The programme is based at the biological institute in Nes Tziyona, the
main research facility for Israel's clandestine arsenal of chemical
and biological weapons.
A scientist there said the task was hugely complicated because both
Arabs and Jews are of semitic origin. But he added: "They have,
however, succeeded in pinpointing a particular characteristic in the
genetic profile of certain Arab communities, particularly the Iraqi
people." The disease could be spread by spraying the organisms into
the air or putting them in water supplies.
The research mirrors biological studies conducted by South African
scientists during the apartheid era and revealed in testimony before
the truth and reconciliation commission.
The idea of a Jewish state conducting such research has already
provoked outrage in some quarters because of parallels with the
genetic experiments of Dr Josef Mengele, the Nazi scientist at
Dedi Zucker, a member of knesset, the Israeli parliament, denounced
the research yesterday. "Morally, based on our history, and our
tradition and our experience, such a weapon is monstrous and should be
denied," he said.
Some experts said that although the concept of an ethnically targeted
weapon was feasible, the practical aspects of creating one were
Dr Daan Goosen, head of a South African chemical and biological
warfare plant, said his team was ordered in the 1980s to develop a
"pigmentation weapon" to target only black people. He said the team
discussed spreading a disease in beer, maize or even vaccinations but
never managed to develop one.
However, a confidential Pentagon report warned last year that
biological agents could be genetically engineered to produce new
lethal weapons. William Cohen, the American defence secretary,
revealed that he had received reports of countries working to create
"certain types of pathogens that would be ethnic-specific". A senior
western intelligence source confirmed last week that Israel was one of
the countries Cohen had in mind.
The "ethno-bomb" claims have been given further credence in Foreign
Report, a Jane's publication that closely monitors security and
defence matters. It reports unnamed South African sources as saying
Israeli scientists have used some of the South African research in
trying to develop an "ethnic bullet" against Arabs.
It also says Israelis discovered aspects of the Arab genetic make-up
by researching on "Jews of Arab origin, especially Iraqis".
The British Medical Association has become so concerned about the
lethal potential of genetically based biological weapons that it has
opened an investigation, which is due to report in January.
Dr Vivienne Nathanson, who organised the research, said: "With an
ethnically targeted weapon, you could even hit groups within a
population. The history of warfare, in which many conflicts have an
ethnic factor, shows us how dangerous this could be."
Porton Down, Britain's biological defence establishment, said last
week that such weapons were theoretically possible. "We have reached a
point now where there is an obvious need for an international
convention to control biological weapons," said a spokesman.
Additional reporting: Matthew Campbell in Washington, Hugh McManners
Next page: Iraq bows to show of force
Subscribe to the paper
Editorial - Another fine mess
Next page: Iraq bows to show of force
Copyright 1998 Times Newspapers Ltd. This service is provided on Times
Newspapers' standard terms and conditions. To inquire about a licence
to reproduce material from The Sunday Times, visit the Syndication