GENET archive

[Index][Thread]

POLICY & REGULATION: ”GMOs are going to be the biggest failure in modern agriculture”



                                  PART 1


------------------------------- GENET-news -------------------------------

TITLE:   KIMBRELL: BIOTECH A ?MISGUIDED EXPERIMENT?

SOURCE:  Capital Press, USA

AUTHOR:  

URL:     http://www.capitalpress.com/oregon/SB-organicology-GMO-021811-art

DATE:    17.02.2011

SUMMARY: "?GMOs are going to be the biggest failure in modern agriculture,? Kimbrell said about genetically modified seeds during the Organicology conference here. ?They are a misguided experiment.? [...] ?But it?s not about organics versus biotech,? he said. ?It?s about conventional farmers losing their export markets because their crops are contaminated. Biotech is not an added tool, but a tool that takes over all the other tools in the toolbox. ..."

----- archive: http://www.genet-info.org/information-services.html -----


KIMBRELL: BIOTECH A ?MISGUIDED EXPERIMENT?

Organic leader says increased reliance on monocultures causes disease, high costs

PORTLAND -- Agriculture developed around the concept of saving seeds. Andrew Kimbrell, from the Center for Food Safety, said the idea of patenting seeds developed around the concept of making money.

?GMOs are going to be the biggest failure in modern agriculture,? Kimbrell said about genetically modified seeds during the Organicology conference here. ?They are a misguided experiment.?

Biotech seeds are not increasing yields or nutrition, he said, the exact opposite of what organic growers are doing.

?Instead of selecting seeds for resiliency and robustness, companies purposely create seed that loses its efficacy after one year,? he said. When seeds become a commodity, that leads to a monoculture crop, disease and infestation, more chemical use and eventually soil destruction.

The ?genetic-industrial complex? feeds myths through the media, he said. Biotech manufacturers especially target the organic community?s focus on overall soil health.

?But it?s not about organics versus biotech,? he said. ?It?s about conventional farmers losing their export markets because their crops are contaminated. Biotech is not an added tool, but a tool that takes over all the other tools in the toolbox. ...

?When a crop is rejected because of contamination, there?s no one to sue,? Kimbrell said. He called for a federal farmer protection act, which would establish liability so farmers suffering economic losses from contamination by genetically modified material can recoup their losses from the manufacturer of that material.

One outcome of the rise of biotech crops is the parallel rise of herbicide-resistant weeds, he said. ?Superweeds challenge all of agriculture. On this issue we can form a coalition with conventional growers -- they?re taking it on the chin more than organic.?



                                  PART 2

------------------------------- GENET-news -------------------------------

TITLE:   NUTIVA PLEDGES USD 25,000 FOR LAWSUIT CHALLENGING USDA?S APPROVAL OF MONSANTO?S GENETICALLY ENGINEERED ALFALFA

SOURCE:  Nutiva, USA

AUTHOR:  Press Release

URL:     http://nutiva.com/articles/nutiva-pledges-25000-for-lawsuit-challenging-usda/

DATE:    14.02.2011

SUMMARY: "Last month the United States Department of Agriculture announced the deregulation of Monsanto?s genetically engineered, Roundup Ready Alfalfa. [...] CFS Executive Director Andrew Kimbrell said, ?CFS?s legal team is the organic community?s last line of defense against this GMO threat to farmers and consumer choice.? Nutiva has pledged $25,000 to CFS in support of this litigation."

----- archive: http://www.genet-info.org/information-services.html -----


NUTIVA PLEDGES USD 25,000 FOR LAWSUIT CHALLENGING USDA?S APPROVAL OF MONSANTO?S GENETICALLY ENGINEERED ALFALFA

Last month the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) announced the deregulation of Monsanto?s genetically engineered, Roundup Ready Alfalfa. This allows unlimited, nationwide commercial planting of the crop, a decision profoundly disappointing to the organic community and one that promises an epic battle to determine the future of organic foods in North America. The Center for Food Safety (CFS) is bringing suit to oppose this decision. CFS, a nonprofit organization, representing 180,000 members across the nation, is focused on curbing the use of harmful food production technologies and promoting organic agriculture. CFS Executive Director Andrew Kimbrell said, ?CFS?s legal team is the organic community?s last line of defense against this GMO threat to farmers and consumer choice.? Nutiva has pledged $25,000 to CFS in support of this litigation.

With Organic Foods Endangered, Who Will Take a Stand Against Monsanto?

Nutiva® founder and CEO, John W. Roulac, comments on the deregulation, ?Nutiva is concerned about the impact that genetically modified organisms are having on our natural world and human health. Since its inception in 1999, Nutiva has exclusively sourced non-GMO ingredients.? According to Roulac, the impending massive spring 2011 planting of Monsanto GMO alfalfa seed could contaminate vast acres of organic food production. ?Now is the time for every corporation that has profited from the organic movement to unite and stop Monsanto. Who else will step forward to protect the sacred natural order for future generations?? If Nutiva, a modest company in a land of large organic firms, can contribute $25,000, what will the largest organic dairy brands, international retailers and distributors do to join in the fight? Nutiva is encouraging all organic advocates to add their financial support to these legal efforts. Roulac is no stranger to taking on specials interests. In 2002, Nutiv
 a, in cooperation with Dr. Bronner?s Magic Soaps, the Hemp Industries Association and Nature?s Path, successfully sued the DEA to establish the rights of Americans to consume hemp foods.

Can Organics Coexist with GMO Alfalfa?

In the view of CFS, if the biotech industry achieves market dominance in numerous crops, the majority of organic foods will be genetically contaminated with foreign genetic material through pollen drift and accidental comingling. Said David Lively, a board member of the Organic Seed Alliance, ?The reality is simple: When farmers lose the genetic purity of their seed, they lose their freedom to operate free of GE contamination.? A genetically engineered (GE) or genetically modified organism (GMO) is created in a laboratory process whereby DNA genes of one species, which may come from bacteria, viruses, insects, or animals, are artificially inserted into genes of an unrelated plant or animal. In 2009, the American Academy of Environmental Medicine (AAEM) stated, ?. . . studies indicate serious health risks associated with GMO food.? These risks include the chance of infertility, immune problems, accelerated aging, faulty insulin regulation and changes in major organs and the ga
 strointestinal system.

The Success of Past CFS Lawsuits

The Center for Food Safety has stopped GMO alfalfa and prevailed against Monsanto and the USDA before. For the past four years, as the result of a lawsuit brought against the USDA by CFS on behalf of farmers and some of the organizations that represent them, there has been a ban on the planting of GE alfalfa. In 2007 a federal court ruled that the USDA?s approval of GE alfalfa violated environmental laws by failing to analyze risks such as the contamination of organic alfalfa and the evolution of glyphosate-resistant weeds. The court banned new plantings of GE alfalfa until the USDA completed a comprehensive environmental impact statement. In June 2010, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld the ban on Monsanto?s Roundup Ready Alfalfa. CFS will be going back to court in the coming weeks with the intent of prevailing in this new case.

About Nutiva®

Nutiva is dedicated to a healthy and sustainable world, demonstrating its mission to nourish people and planet by using delicious organic ingredients, enriching the soil, and donating 1% of sales to sustainable-agriculture groups. Founded in 1999, Nutiva is the world?s best-selling brand of nutritious organic hemp, coconut and chia superfoods. Its products are offered nationwide, as well as in Canada, Mexico, and the European Union, at more than 10,000 natural-food retailers.