GENET archive


[genet-news] AGRICULTURE & DEVELOPMENT: GM battle hotting up in India

                                  PART 1

------------------------------- GENET-news -------------------------------


SOURCE: Ground Reality, India

AUTHOR: Devinder Sharma


DATE:   04.04.2009

------------------ archive: ------------------


>From North to South, the battle for saving our favourite vegetable brinjal from being poisoned with genetic modification is heating up. The day (April 2) a large number of protestors under the banner of Safe Food Alliance, and led by Mr Vellaiyan, a leader of the Tamil Nadu Traders Association, were arrested for staging a peaceful protest against the field trials for GM corn being held inside the premises of the Tamil Nadu Agricultural University at Coimbatore, Swami Ramdev launched a nation-wide campaign to protect the country from the influx of dangerous GM crops/foods at an impressive opening ceremony of the 2nd phase of the Patanjali Yogpeeth at Haridwar. A special debate on ?swadeshi se swablamban talk? was beamed live on Aastha and Sanskar TV channels in 170 countries.

I had the privilege and honour of being invited to speak at this panel. There were some 10,000 people in the new auditorium, and millions watched it live on TV. We will talk about Swami Ramdev?s vision of village self-reliance some other day, but let us first look at what is happening on the GM front.

The same day, Dr Rajaram Deshmuck, vice-chancellor of the Mahatma Phule Krishi Vidyapeeth in Kolahapur, announced his university?s decision not to allow any more research trials of GM crops. This is perhaps the first agriculture university in the country that I know of which has taken this bold and beautiful stand. The same day, Sangita Sharma of Annadana, Bangalore, made a presentation on how safe is your food, after screening the film Poison on the Platter, to a large audience in the Ramchandrapuram math in Shimoga/Karnataka. A day later, Sridhar from Thanal and Dr V S Vijayan, chairman of the Kerala Biodiversity Board, spoke at an interactive session with lawyers in Cochin/Kerala, after screening the film ?Poison on the Platter?.

While all this may look very heartening to those who want to live in harmony with nature, and want to protect their future generations from being turned into slaves of the food companies (and their breed of pets, the insensitive scientists), there is a renewed thrust on pushing GM crops in the United States and Europe. In the last week of February, the Windsor Castle in London hosted a major conference where the focus was on why the need to take a relook at GM crops. And as you guessed it right, they used the guilt arguement that if UK does not go in to GM crops research, millions in developing world will die of hunger.

The US President Obama, who many believe to be an agent of change, has come as a big disappointment. Like Monsanto, which pollutes and contaminates the world with its risky and dangerous GM technology, but keeps its own canteen free of GM ingredients, President Obama too follows the same prescription. His wife Michelle Obama is laying out an organic garden in White House to feed her own children and her guests with safe and healthy food, but have no qualms when it comes to the people of America or for that matter people living in Africa, from where their ancestors came from. Treating the people as subjects who deserve only unhealthy food, because it bolsters the profits of agri-business companies, the US Senate Foreign Relations Committee has passed a bill -- S 384 -- that marks a significant change in the US agricultural research policy. The US will now fund GM crop research for Africa.

This is in complete contravention of the Bumper?s Amendment that the senate had passed in 1980?s. I have written about the Bumper?s Amendment (Bumper was the name of a US senator) in my book GATT to WTO: Seeds of Despair (Konark Publishers, New Delhi), and I will bring the salient features of the Bumper?s Amendment to you in the days to come.

It is therefore quite obvious that your fight to save your food from the GM vultures not going to be easy. The biotech industry is gearing up to manipulate public opinion. Clive James, the chairman of a so called international NGO -- ISAAA --which in reality is an industry outfit, has sent a couple of DVDs to noted film maker Mahesh Bhatt, explaining how essential GM crops are for the world -- a clear indication that the documentary film ?Poison on the Platter? has surely unruffled some feathers.

What amazes me is that when ?Poison on the Platter? is screened at a number of places, some scientists and cheerleaders will stand up and ask that the film does not carry the ?other? opinion, it is therefore not balanced. While Mahesh Bhatt has very clearly said (and it is also in the film) that the industry was approached but they declined to participate in the film, the same question has never been asked to ISAAA or Monsanto. Show me one film produced by Monsanto/Syngenta/Du Pont or ISAAA that provides space for any dissenting voice? And I am not surprised that none of their own team of supporters have ever questioned the need to ?balance? out the debate by bringing in the other viewpoint in their own propaganda films. So much so for objectivity in science.

The print and electronic media does the same. When I and my colleagues hold a press conference, reporters are usually told to also take the industry viewpoint before they write the news report. I am have nothing against this approach. But why is that when Monsanto or Mahyco hold a press conference, my view or that of my esteemed colleagues is never taken? Why is it the same objectivity is very conveniently sacrificed when it comes to big business and multinationals?

I am sure you know the answer.

Meanwhile, the BJP election manifesto too comes as a whiff of fresh air. It has expressed confidence in India?s traditional agriculture, has talked of assuring a fixed income for farmers, and has very loudly said that GM crops/foods will not be allowed unless its long-term impact on soil, human health and environment have been ascertained. Well, as expected, this has upset the dominant group within the party, and we will have to wait and watch as to which way the party swings after the elections.

While the GM scene hots up, I am keenly looking forward to a brinjal festival that a Karnataka NGO, Sahaja Samrudha, is planning to organise in Bangalore on April 5. It is with a lot of hope that I view such activities. Creating more awareness, and disseminating the right kind of message across the country is an urgent need. The people of this country have ample wisdom. They have demonstrated it time and again. They were not overawed by the ?Shining India? election slogan in 2004. They stood up, and voted the party out of power. They can certainly see through the infectious design of the food companies and agriculture scientists. They too need to be shown the door, and only the people of this great country can do that.

This is where I see Swami Ramdev showing us the path to self-reliance. Like millions in this country, and across the globe, I have tremendous faith in him. He is like a ray of hope emerging from the dark clouds, who has already acquired mass support. The manner in which people are joining him and feel drawned to his honesty and courage of conviction, clearly shows that people are fed up with the present economic, science and agricultural policies. They want a change.

Nevertheless, in the days to come the battle against GM will only get fiercer. Your silence has already cost the nation dearly. I call it as a conspiracy of silence, and you have been party to it knowingly or unknowingly. It is now your chance to stand up and be counted.

                                  PART 2

------------------------------- GENET-news -------------------------------


SOURCE: Down To Earth, India

AUTHOR: Shubhranshu Choudhary


DATE:   15.04.2009

------------------ archive: ------------------


Shubhranshu Choudhary finds out why farmers? suicide is such a touchy subject in Chhattisgarh

Nawagarh in Durg district of Chhattisgarh is a small place by all standards. As in all small places here too everyone knows everybody and it was not difficult to find a local journalist as soon as we reached Nawagarh. We were looking for help to investigate the story of a farmer?s suicide in Chhattisgarh. A simple enquiry at a local paan shop on the roadside got us the address and directions to the most famous journalist in town.

Here journalists wear many hats. Ashish Jain runs a grocery shop apart from being a correspondent for a daily from Chhattisgarh?s capital Raipur. A big picture of him with a state Congress leader in his drawing room tells us that he is also active in local politics apart from journalism and his shop.

While waiting for tea I asked him if there have been many incidents of farmers? suicide in Nawagarh lately?

?No, we have never heard of any farmer?s suicide here,? Ashish said very confidently.

He was, in fact, quite surprised to hear my question. His brother, who is a correspondent for another daily from Raipur and was in the shop next door while we chatted in the drawing room, overheard our conversation and made a quick call to the police inspector of the town and confirmed that no farmers had committed suicide in the area.

I took out a list provided by the police headquarters in Raipur and started counting. It had names and addresses of 23 farmers who had committed suicide in the last 18 months under Nawagarh police station. So how far were the villages listed here? I wanted to know. Ashish had a close look at the list and said that all the villages in the list were within 4-5 km from Nawagarh.

But he still would not believe us and was shocked to hear that according to data of the National Crime Records Bureau, Chhattisgarh has highest rate of farmers? suicide per one lakh population in the country. ?I have never read about it anywhere in the newspapers,? he said.

?The figure is not just for this year. Chhattisgarh remains at the top of the list every year since its inception. 1,593 farmers committed suicide in the state last year according to the data provided by state police to the National Crime Records Bureau,? I said. It means four farmers die every day by committing suicide and in the tally, Durg is just behind Raipur, which tops the list amongst the districts of Chhattisgarh.

Two hundred and six farmers committed suicide in Durg last year alone. Ashish was bewildered. After taking directions from him, we set off to meet the families of some of the farmers from the police list who committed suicide last year. There was one farmer from Mohtara village, who as per the list had decided to put an end to his life because of a heavy loan. We thought of going to his family first.

?Pardesi, who died?? Yes. ?Go along the pond and knock at the last house to your left. That is Pardesi Sahu?s house,? people told us at the village square in Mohtara.

Raju looks younger than the twenty years he claims his age to be. But he is the eldest in the house now. He needs to take care of sister Rajmati and younger brother Rajesh after father?s demise. His mother died a natural death six-seven years ago and his two elder sisters were married before that.

Raju has no answer to why his father may have consumed poison. ?May be he was unhappy with my mother?s death? he said. But that was six-seven years ago. ?Maybe he was drinking too much,? he answered reluctantly.

Sawat Sahu, an old friend of Pardesi joined us by this time and objected to this remark from Raju. ?Yes, Pardesi used to drink when he met his friends of that type but he was definitely not a drunkard.?

?How much loan did he have?? I asked. ?It was around Rs 1 lakh,? Raju replied. Who was the loan from? ?We have a Rs 10,000 loan from the bank and the rest was from relatives and friends.?

Did they come to your house to ask for the money? ?Yes, they used to come to our house asking for the money. But I have now returned most of the loans,? Raju said. ?You have returned the loans, how?? I asked.

?I sold 55 decimal of land after my father?s death to repay the loans to relatives. I have repaid Rs 60,000. But there is another 30,000 still to be paid to Padum Guruji in Jhal and one more relative in Semarsal.?

?I have not paid the bank yet.? But I would have thought that being your relatives, you can return the money to them later, they would wait, and you would return the money to the bank first, I said.

?No. I did not want the relationships to go sour. My father died in shame that he could not return their loan so that is the first thing I did after my father?s death,? Raju said.

The story was becoming clearer now. Sawat Sahu sitting nearby pitched in: ?Though Pardesi had 2 acres (0.8 hectares, ha) he used to take another 4-5 acres (about 2 ha) on lease every year. He thought he would repay the loans with income from the extra land but the crop failed.?

Pardesi?s elder sister also joined in by now. ?Many years ago we used to go out to work to other states and had bought this land with the help of that earning. It would have been better had my brother continued to go out to do labour and not insisted on farming. This farming has killed him. Pardesi had sold 2 acres (0.8 ha) earlier as well, to repay loans in the past. By this time he had only 2 acres (0.8 ha) left and could not bear the thought of having to sell them too,? she said.

It was quite obvious that suicide is such a negative thing socially that people do not want to think about the reason a family member may have committed suicide. Or even if they think about it, they try to avoid discussing it with outsiders and it is difficult to get the story out as a journalist, unless one is prepared to be very persistent.

We now moved to nearby Ranbod village, where Beturam Sahu committed suicide. He also had 2 acres (0.8 ha). His wife is sick and weak, and it is obvious that she has not been able to manage to put together enough money even for food. She lives with a small baby in their mud hut next to the village pond.

Though the crop is yet to be harvested, this year the elder son Lakhnu has already left for Agra to earn some money by labour work. They have a loan of Rs 30,000 on them.

?The crop is so bad this year that we will not even be able to save any seeds. There were no rains at all,? said Santosh, Lakhnu?s friend. ?That?s why Lakhnu left even before harvesting the crop. There is nothing left to harvest in his land this time. It is all gone. He is worried how will he repay these loans.?

Jeevan, a friend of Beturam, said ?Beturam died due to loans. He had no fight with anyone. He was also not keeping well lately and burnt himself one day. Here every farmer is in debt. I have 15 acres (6 ha) but I too have around Rs 27,000 loan from the bank.?

Santosh sitting next to him said, ?There is a case pending on my land so I can?t get loan from the bank. I have taken a loan of Rs 13,000 from the moneylender. Lakhnu also borrowed from the moneylender because the land is still in his father?s name. So the bank did not give any loan to him this time.?

How is it that these obvious farmers? suicide stories are not visible to journalists like Ashish Jain, who live so close? It is surprising.

To go to the third village Nandal, we needed to come back to Nawagarh as Nandal is on the other side of Nawagarh.

Shatrughan Sahu of nearby Dharampura village was on his motorbike. We stopped by to ask him the direction for Nandal. I also asked him, ?Have you heard of farmer suicides in the area?? Shatrughan was the first person in the entire region to accept, ?Yes, farmers are committing suicide here but they are all the idiot ones,? he said.

Shatrughan has two shops in Nawagarh town. On further enquiry he said, ?The water level has gone down below 250 feet here. It used to be at 40 feet few years ago. Most of the farmers here are indebted and only God can save the ones who do not have a bore well.?

Like everyone here, state chief minister Raman Singh also says, ?Not a single farmer has committed suicide due to loan in the state ever.?

The police records for last few years for Durg district have 13 deaths listed as farmers? suicide due to debt. Not only that, 31 farmers are listed as having committed suicide due to economic distress.

Now we moved on to Nandal with directions from Shatrughan. Teerathram Sahu in Nandal used to work alone on his farm. Both his sons went to work as masons in Pune. He sold half an acre (0.2 ha) to repay a loan few years ago but since his sons started sending money from Pune he did not have to borrow any money.

After the father?s death the younger son Arjun has stayed back and does farming. ?My father had no loan but he wasted all the money we sent from Pune in farming. He used to take 8-9 acres (about 3.2-3.6 ha) on lease and thought he would earn handsome amount from that, but the crop failed,? Arjun said. His father was sick as well.

This year Arjun has taken only 3.5 acre (1.4 ha) on lease. ?There is no profit in farming. All our income from Pune has gone waste. We have a very small unpaid loan of Rs 2,500. But my father died of the guilt of wasting all our earning. We tried for a borewell few years ago but that failed,? Arjun said.

It was getting dark now. But on the way back we decided to stop by at Netram Yadav?s house in village Bhainsa. Netram was educated till class 4 and had 3 acres (1.2 ha) and used to take more land for farming on lease every year.

His wife can?t think of any other reason why he committed suicide. ?He was worried about the loan of Rs 15,000 he had taken from the moneylender. There is an interest of Rs 5 per month on every Rs 100 and he was worried how he would repay it. He was a good farmer. He had no fight in the family.?

His widow is left with three children to bring up. Two of them go to school and the youngest is a toddler.

Netram had some problem in his eyes and that was giving him trouble. His brother Santram now goes to work as labourer for farmers from Haryana who have bought large tracts of land and grow sugarcane on them. Their land is not irrigated and they can grow only 10-12 bags (of 75 kg) of paddy per acre.

Suicide is a complex issue and needs deeper investigation. A journalistic enquiry can only provide pointers to this problem?to draw attention of the people who are in a position to study the matter in detail and take appropriate action.

But will anyone heed the pointers? Not only Chief Minister Raman Singh but the opposition Congress also does not see any farmers? suicide in the state. Some members of the farmers? wing of the Congress party tried unsuccessfully to include the subject in the Congress manifesto for the last assembly election.

A high-profile Congress leader told me righteously, ?We also visit the villages. We do not see any farmer committing suicide. So how can we include the issue in the manifesto??

Maybe the reason no one can see is because no rich farmer is committing suicide.

Who cares for the poor and idiot farmers anyway!



European NGO Network on Genetic Engineering

Hartmut MEYER (Mr)

news & information

phone....... +49-531-5168746

fax......... +49-531-5168747

email....... news(*)

skype....... hartmut_meyer


GENET-news is a public news service from GENET.
Visit GENET website to learn more about GENET: