GENET archive


[genet-news] BUSINESS & PLANTS: Monsanto GM-corn harvest fails massively in South Africa

                                  PART 1

------------------------------- GENET-news -------------------------------


SOURCE: Digital Journal, South Africa

AUTHOR: Adriana Stuijt


DATE:   29.03.2009

------------------ archive: ------------------


South African farmers suffered millions of dollars in lost income when 82,000 hectares of genetically-manipulated corn (maize) failed to produce hardly any seeds.The plants look lush and healthy from the outside. Monsanto has offered compensation.

Monsanto blames the failure of the three varieties of corn planted on these farms, in three South African provinces,on alleged ?underfertilisation processes in the laboratory?. Some 280 of the 1,000 farmers who planted the three varieties of Monsanto corn this year, have reported extensive seedless corn problems.

Urgent investigation demanded

However environmental activitist Marian Mayet, director of the Africa-centre for biosecurity in Johannesburg, demands an urgent government investigation and an immediate ban on all GM-foods, blaming the crop failure on Monsanto?s genetically-manipulated technology.

Willem Pelser, journalist of the Afrikaans Sunday paper Rapport, writes from Nelspruit that Monsanto has immediately offered the farmers compensation in three provinces - North West, Free State and Mpumalanga. The damage-estimates are being undertaken right now by the local farmers? cooperative, Grain-SA. Monsanto claims that ?less than 25%? of three different corn varieties were ?insufficiently fertilised in the laboratory?.

80% crop failure

However Mayet says Monsanto was grossly understating the problem. According to her own information, some farms have suffered up to 80% crop failures. The centre is strongly opposed to GM-food and biologically-manipulated technology in general.

?Monsanto says they just made a mistake in the laboratory, however we say that biotechnology is a failure. You cannot make a ?mistake? with three different varieties of corn.?

Demands urgent government investigation:

?We have been warning against GM-technology for years, we have been warning Monsanto that there will be problems,? said Mayet. She calls for an urgent government investigation and an immediate ban on all GM-foods in South Africa.

Of the 1,000 South African farmers who planted Monsanto?s GM-maize this year, 280 suffered extensive crop failure, writes Rapport.

Monsanto?s local spokeswoman Magda du Toit said the ?company is engaged in establishing the exact extent of the damage on the farms?. She did not want to speculate on the extent of the financial losses suffered right now.

Managing director of Monsanto in Africa, Kobus Lindeque, said however that ?less than 25% of the Monsanto-seeded farms are involved in the loss?. He says there will be ?a review of the seed-production methods of the three varieties involved in the failure, and we will made the necessary adjustments.?

He denied that the problem was caused in any way by ?bio-technology?. Instead, there had been ?insufficient fertilisation during the seed-production process?.

And Grain-SA?s Nico Hawkins says they ?are still support GM-technology; ?We will support any technology which will improve production.? see

He also they were ?satisfied with Monsanto?s handling of the case,? and said Grain-SA was ?closely involved in the claims-adjustment methodology? between the farmers and Monsanto.

Farmers told Rapport that Monsanto was ?bending over backwards to try and accommodate them in solving the problem.

?It?s a very good gesture to immediately offer to compensate the farmers for losses they suffered,? said Kobus van Coller, one of the Free State farmers who discovered that his maize cobs were practically seedless this week.

?One can?t see from the outside whether a plant is unseeded. One must open up the cob leaves to establish the problem,? he said. The seedless cobs show no sign of disease or any kind of fungus. They just have very few seeds, often none at all.

The South African supermarket-chain Woolworths already banned GM-foods from its shelves in 2000. However South African farmers have been producing GM-corn for years: they were among the first countries other than the United States to start using the Monsanto products.

The South African government does not require any labelling of GM-foods. Corn is the main staple food for South Africa?s 48-million people.

The three maize varieties which failed to produce seeds were designed with a built-in resistance to weed-killers, and manipulated to increase yields per hectare, Rapport writes.

                                  PART 2

------------------------------- GENET-news -------------------------------


SOURCE: The Times, South Africa

AUTHOR: Hans Lombard


DATE:   29.03.2009

------------------ archive: ------------------


Hans Lombard, agricultural analyst and consultant to the agricultural biotechnology industry, Cresta

With reference to Bobby Jordan?s article ?GM maize fails to produce? (March 22), I would like to set a few aspects right. Hans Lombard

No genetically modified maize anywhere in the world, after more than 12 years of production (10 in South Africa), has ever failed to produce.

Pollination variation is not uncommon and can be influenced by several factors, such as weather or agronomic practices.

In this case, agronomists found there could have been an error in the seed production method. This can be rectified and has nothing, whatsoever, to do with genetic modification. The same seed production error with conventional maize would have had a similar result.

Seed companies have experienced similar issues in the past, long before the advent of GM technology. Andrew Taynton?s reference that ?we regularly come across unintended side effects from GM plants? is nonsense. There is no substantiated scientific evidence to prove this.

More than 60% of the maize grown in South Africa is genetically modified. And, as Jordan reported, Grain SA confirmed farmers were happy with GM maize because of higher yields. Worldwide, 37.3 million hectares of GM maize is being planted, increasing annually by 10%, with no side effects or failed production.



European NGO Network on Genetic Engineering

Hartmut MEYER (Mr)

news & information

phone....... +49-531-5168746

fax......... +49-531-5168747

email....... news(*)

skype....... hartmut_meyer


GENET-news is a public news service from GENET.
Visit GENET website to learn more about GENET: