GENET archive


2-Plants: First Bt cotton grown in Pakistan

------------------------------- GENET-news -------------------------------

TITLE:  First Bt Cotton Grown in Pakistan
SOURCE: Pakissan, Pakistan, by Ijaz Ahmad Rao
DATE:   21 Mar 2006

------------------ archive: ------------------

First Bt Cotton Grown in Pakistan
  By   Ijaz Ahmad Rao - Bahawalpur

Cotton is an important cash crop for Pakistan known as "white gold". It
accounts for 8.2 percent of the value added in agriculture and about 3.2
percent to GDP; around two thirds of the country's export earnings are
from the cotton made-up and textiles which adds over $2.5 billion to the
national economy; while hundreds of ginning factories and textile mills
in the country heavily depends upon cotton. Life of millions of farmers
is dependent on this crop, in addition to millions of people employed
along the entire cotton value chain, from weaving to textile and garment
exports The area under the cultivation of cotton crops has been increased
significantly in the last 30 years - around 7.85 million acres in 2005-06
as compared to 7.2 million acres in 2002-03. Beside being the world's
fourth-largest cotton producer and the third largest exporter of raw
cotton and a leading exporter of yarn in the world our yield per acres
ranks 13th in the world; as a result Pakistan annually imports around
1.5-2.00 million bales of cotton to meet growing demand from local
textile mills; therefore it has become vital for Pakistan to increase its
yield per acre. 

 There are many reasons for low yields of cotton crop in Pakistan - high
price of agriculture inputs (seeds, fertilizers, pesticides etc), higher
intensity of insects and pests attack, shortage of good quality and
varieties of seeds, deficiency of water for irrigation, lack of advance
technologies, awareness and agro-professionalism, and adulterations in
pesticides, fertilizers and seeds.  It is unfortunate that there is no
proper cotton crop insurance system available in Pakistan, while
government does not provide any support or subsidy to cotton growers for
inputs - resulted in frustration and lack of motivation in cotton
growers. Farmers are facing with a number of risks till marketing of
their crops including unexpected factors like inflation, high price of
energy, unfair competition and speculation in open market by big cotton
buyers. Although, government claims that they have excellent micro-
economy policy to improve the livelihood of farmers and elimination of
poverty in rural area through bank-loans offered to the farmers, however,
the interest rates are fairly high.

 Agriculture biotechnology is helping today to provide people with more
and better crops, food and holds even greater promise for the future.
Green revolution farming methods are coming to an end with declining
yields due to environmental and soil degradation, loss of seedling
varieties and high input costs. So, many farmers around the world are
turning to genetic engineered varieties (GE) to confront with new
challenges. Many Asian countries including China, India, Indonesia,
Malaysia, Philippines, Thailand, Pakistan and Vietnam are giving high
priority to plant biotechnology research in the hope of addressing the
pressing challenges related to improving productivity, farmers
livelihoods, driving rural development, and meeting food security
demands. Many of these countries focus their biotechnology research on
food crops and non food crops and crops of high commercial value in the
hope of meeting increasing food requirements and reducing use of
pesticides and poverty alleviation in rural area. 

 If we look at the Pakistan scenario, two major types of pests are
damaging our cotton crops - sucking and chewing; to certain extent it is
easier to control sucking pest by strong pesticides but is very
challenging to control chewing pests - Bollworms known as "Sundies" -
American, Army, Pink and Spotted - cause major devastations in the cotton
crop fields; as a result of this, overall both quality of lint and
production of cotton have declined substantially. Moreover, recent
disaster resulting from the cotton leaf curl virus (CLCV) spread in
Punjab and Sindh pushed our institutes like Pakistan Atomic Energy
Commission (PAEC), National Institute for Biotechnology and Genetic
Engineering (NIBGE) and Nuclear Institute of Agriculture and Biology
(NIAB) in Faisalabad, and National center of Excellence in Molecular
Biology (NCEMB) at Punjab University Lahore to cope with such problems;
significant amount of financial resources and manpower have been
committed by the Government of Pakistan for developing genetically
modified (GM) local cotton varieties. 

Pakistan has already surpassed the major obstacle on its way to adapting
to biotechnology by enacting the Biosafety Rules in April 2005. These
rules setup legal requirements for import, export, transport, and
handling of biological agents, genetic engineering organisms or vectors,
seeds, crops and foods, besides setting conditions for the researchers;
seeds developers and companies. Usually it takes two to three years to do
proper assessment for any Biotech crops before its commercialization.
Whereas, Pakistan Atomic energy Commission (PAEC) had sought special
permission in 1997 from the Ministry of Environment under "Voluntary Code
of Conduct for release of GMO into the environment" prepared by NIBGE;
and it conducted, checked and analyzed many safety tests on various
cotton varieties which contain gene of genetically modified organism
called Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt), a bacterium that is deadly to the

 In May 2005 PAEC provided 40,000.00 Kg basic seed of Bt cotton (insect
resistant) varieties "IR-FH-901", "IR-NIBGE-2", "IR-CIM-448" and "IR-CIM-
443"; which have been grown over 8,000 acres of land in season 2005-06.
Its encouraging outcomes have surprised every one from seed companies to
the farmers who cultivated these varieties. These early users of Bt
cotton have been tightly screened and evaluated by PAEC on the bases of
their capacity to follow Bio-safety rules. 

 Farmers, who cultivated these Bt cotton varieties at heart of cotton
growing regions in Punjab - Bahawalpur, Multan, Muzaffer Garh and Karor
Pakka; observed and evaluated independently its resistance and
susceptibility to different pests including factors like abiotic stress
and yield than compared it with non Bt cotton varieties grown in the same
locations. A large number of farmers have visited these fields, and
become aware of the benefits of the locally developed Bt cotton. 

Although germination of these Bt cotton seed varieties vary from 65 %, to
85 %, but mixing or impurities were less than 2 %. In the beginning
overall attack of "Lashkari Sundi" "American Sundi" and other bollworms
remained low as compared to previous years but attack of sucking pests
like Jassid, Whitefly, Thrips and other Aphid were high in both Bt and
non Bt cotton crops. No serious incidence of cotton leaf curl virus
disease was reported in Bt cotton varieties. Heat stress in cotton crop
was also recorded in different region, however no stress was observed in
Bt cotton varieties. Army, Pink and Spotted bollworm were active from
July to October with peak infestation during September but Army remained
in the field after spray for limited time period; IR-901, IR 448 and
NIBGE 2 with minimum damage was recorded as compare to non Bt cotton
crops. It is worth mentioning that infestation of American, Pink and
Spotted sundies remained significantly low throughout the season in Bt
varieties as compare to infestation in non Bt cotton varieties. Maximum
alive larvae of Army, pink and spotted bollworm were recorded in fields
of non Bt varieties around 7-8 per 15 plants while only larvae of Army
bollworm were recorded in IR- 448, IR 901 and NIBGE-1 around 3 - 4 larvae
in 15 plants. It is also important that newly hatched Helicoverpa
Armigera when eat leaves of the Bt cotton crops died after few days; no
larvae reached to pupal stage while in non Bt it has developed into pupa.
Significant number of spray has decline in Bt cotton varieties; 4 - 5
applications as compare to non Bt cotton crop 6 - 9; most of spray were
used to control sucking pests; however in chewing; pests spray was
required to control Lashkari sundi. Although Bt cotton also provides
significant control of targeted bollworms but supplemental foliar
insecticide sprays are occasionally required to keep other bollworms from
causing excessive damage in Bt fields. 

 Bt cotton varieties yielded significantly more per acre as compare to
non Bt cotton varieties - an average 23-28 maund (1 Maund = 40 Kg) per
acres versus 17-20 maund to traditional cotton varieties.  This
translates into more than 30 percent increase in yield. It is noteworthy
that in Bt cotton crops average number of cotton Bolls per plant are 120
while average Boll weight is app. 1.75 grams including seeds and number
of plants per acre are as recommended by the department of agriculture.
The economical gain by using Bt cotton per acre is more than Pak Rs.
3,000 at the market sale price of Rs. 1100/ Maund. In Pakistan average
cotton grower has 10 acres of land; increase in such small income per
acre would improve his quality of life. It is expected that cotton
growers should have Bt seeds of the above varieties for at least 75,000
acres of land in year 2006-07. 

 Besides cotton lint; tons of edible oil is extracted from cottonseed in
addition to that over two million tons of oil seedcake is also produced
as feed for livestock and poultry. Series of safety studies have been
carried out at NIBGE including health risk assessment and environmental
concerns; it conducted that Bt cotton leaves/feed has no health hazards
and side effects on human, animals and it safe for environment. These
studies created a positive consciousness and confidence among the
Pakistani scientist and people about Bt cotton. In February 2006, World
Trade Organization ruling against European Union; directs the EU to end
its defacto moratorium on biotech crops and GM food. EU had an effective
ban on biotech foods for six years beginning in 1998 while ended its
moratorium in 2004; it began allowing imports of GM products on a case-
by-case basis, individual. EU grows less than 1% of the world's gene-
modified crops and has approved more than 30 GM food and animal products
since 1994. Washington has said it will continue with its WTO case until
it is convinced that all applications for approval are being decided on
scientific rather than political grounds; the ruling supports a 15-year
study funded by the European Union itself found that biotech plants and
products have not "shown any new risks to human health or the
environment" and concluded that these foods are in fact safer than
conventional foods- this curb on imports of GM foods should bring great
benefits to farmers and rural areas worldwide.

 Today, all major cotton producing countries are benefiting from the
cultivation of Bt Cotton. In the last season 54 percent of cotton crops
grown in USA, 76 percent in China and 80 percent in Australia were with
"single" or "double" Bt gene technology. India, the world's third-largest
cotton-grower has cultivated 1.36 million acres of Bt cotton crops. It is
expected that within two years more than half the world's cotton may be
grown from genetically modified crops. 

 Pakistan also realizes the significance of Bt Cotton, and the top
political leadership including the Prime Minister Shaukat Aziz himself
has said to a delegation of farmers that government would allow farmers
to grow Bt cotton soon, which confirms government's policy of being open
to genetically modified crops in the near future. Other ministers have
also spoken in favor of adopting the Bt Cotton. 

Crop reviews carried out by various independent sources illustrate that
unrecorded sowing of new Bt cotton varieties also played its role in
increasing cotton productivity, with unofficial estimates suggesting 3 to
5 percent of the area in Punjab and 10 to 15 percent of the area in Sindh
may have been planted in transgenic cotton. 

 We shall discuss the unapproved varieties of Bt Cotton separately
because these exotic varieties are throwing different and some very
serious challenges to the cotton crop in Pakistan. Nevertheless, the
indigenously developed IR-cotton varieties with Bt gene have proven
resistance to cotton's major bollworms, and have a potential to reduce
the number of pesticide sprays and will be friendly to environmental. It
will increase yield per acre and reduce cost of production. However, few
issues related to seed quality have been reported, which have no link
with Bt technology and are germplasm specific. These problems must be
addressed in the new version of Bt varieties like size of bolls, maturity
period etc. 

 Biotechnology offers tremendous benefits to the agriculture in Pakistan.
But in order to benefit from its true potential, government and all key
stakeholders including farmers, seed companies, R & D institutes, seed
dealers and traders involved in commercial activity related to seed will
have to act responsibly and ethically. If we choose to ignore regulatory
frameworks that govern the chain of activity, and international
agreements on biosafety that Pakistan is signatory to, to make quick
bucks or in an attempt to provide a speedy access of technology to the
farmers, we shall end up losing the benefits from the technology in the
long run by undermining it. We have to ensure effective, stringent, and
transparent enforcement of Biosafety Rules 2005, Seed Act 1976, and
Punjab Cotton Control Ordinance, to encourage the introduction of
technology through legal means with its complete package of benefits.

Farmers! Please be advised that...

- Select only approved Bt Cotton varieties by the Government of Pakistan,
and avoid pirated Bt cotton varieties or fake bands under name of Bt
cotton seeds available in the market. These varieties could potentially
serious damage crops, our health and environment. The uncontrolled
release of genetically engineered varieties might irreversibly damage our
cotton crop, just like "Banana Bunchy virus" from untested and non
approved variety of banana from Australia has done in Sindh. These exotic
and unapproved Bt cotton varieties are invariably susceptible to Jassid
attack and are very vulnerable to CLCV. In year 2002 "Burewala visrus"
which resulted in huge losses to the cotton crop in the country, was due
to the introduction of a foreign untested variety that was not suitable
to our soil and climate.

- Bt seeds are highly dependent on agro climatic conditions, genotype of
the variety and management of crop. In some areas, certain Bt varieties
may be inappropriate for local growing conditions and may fail to produce
satisfactory results. For example under high night temperatures and under
hot dry conditions, bolls may drop off the plants. Therefore use only
those approved Bt cottonseeds varieties; which are tested for your local
agro-climatic conditions.

- Bt varieties provides protection only against certain pests (sundies)
such as, American sundie, Pink and Spotted sundies; but not against Army
or Lashkari sundi; you have to spray if you find pests which cannot be
controlled other wise you will lose your crops and money. 

- Right dose of Bt toxin "Cry-protein" in very crucial in each Bt seed;
if we keep growing the same Bt seed over time; the right amount of Bt
toxin will reduce and pests will develop resistance to Bt toxin - so it
will harm our agriculture, may be health, environment and undermine the
emerging technology. 

- So far, no Bt cotton developer has claimed that Bt varieties would
increase yield due to presence of genetically modified organism; however,
the increase in yield can be achieved since the crop is protected from
the damages caused by pests.

- Don't be disheartened from the original technology, as the half-baked
technology in your access does not represent the true benefits of Bt Cotton.

European NGO Network on Genetic Engineering

Hartmut MEYER (Mr)
news & information

phone....... +49-531-5168746
fax......... +49-531-5168747
email....... news(*)
skype....... hartmut_meyer

   GENET-news mailing list