GENET archive


3-Food: Food safety spawns public concern in China

-------------------------------- GENET-news -------------------------------

TITLE:  Food safety spawns public concern
SOURCE: China Daily
DATE:   26 Mar 2005

------------------- archive: -------------------

Food safety spawns public concern

Xi Ping, a Shanghai resident, had already consumed a dozen bottles of a
name-brand pickle product when he learned from a television report that
his favourite food contains Sudan I, a carcinogenic dye used mainly to
colour shoe polish and other waxes.

"I have been taking poison without even knowing it," he said, bitterly.
"I had wondered how the vegetables could be made so delicious I know. And I learned it's dangerous."

In no way is Xi's story exceptional. In recent weeks, Sudan I has been
found in a variety of foods sold in a dozen Chinese provinces and
municipalities, including Beijing, the nation's capital.

The dye is used as an additive not only in tomato paste and ketchup, but
also in chili sauce, pepper oil and pickles that are prepared with
traditional methods. Fast food outlets, including some KFC branches, have
used the dye-tainted products.

The latest discovery of Sudan I in foods follows another food-related
tragedy that shocked the nation and is still fresh in people's minds.
Thirteen infants died of malnutrition and 171 fell ill in Fuyang, East
China's Anhui Province, after being fed with a blend of infant formula
that contained mainly starch and little dried milk.

The case was cracked last May. Several local officials were disciplined
for dereliction of duty or inaction. Some heartless merchants were jailed
for producing or selling the so-called "powdered milk."

About the same time, 40 people in Guangdong Province were hospitalized
after drinking liquor adulterated with industrial alcohol. Fourteen died
in that incident.

As a deputy to the National the People's Congress (NPC), China's top
legislature, Zhang Wenrong, a businessman in Shanghai, spent nearly six
months beginning last June in an investigation of foods sold in 221 local

Poor food quality

In a 64-page report on his findings, he listed 150 "questionable" foods:
sleeve-fish preserved in formalin, bamboo shoots kept fresh with
industrial sulfur, cuttlefish dyed with ink, and moldy oranges covered
with a coating of paraffin.

On the eve of World Consumer Rights Day, March 15, the State
Administration of Industry and Commerce (SAIC) reported that in the past
year, it had handled 110,000 cases concerning food safety. In the
process, it discovered 920 million yuan (US$111 million) worth of
counterfeit and substandard goods.

The State Quality and Quarantine Administration (SQQA) tested 2,000 food
samples the same year and found one-fifth of them were below the State-
imposed quality standards.

Many Chinese are growing increasingly nervous. Like Xi Ping, the man in
Shanghai who has stopped eating pickles, they are changing their eating

He Jiguo, a professor with the Food School of the China Agricultural
University in Beijing, views the phenomenon from two perspectives.

"On the one hand," he said, "people are more concerned than ever with the
quality of what they eat, in particular with whether foods are safe. Gone
are those days when they ate simply in order to be full."

"On the other hand," he continued, "legislation on food must be
improved." The professor cited a report published by the SQQA recently to
back up his views.

In 2004, according to the report, the SQQA surveyed a million producers
of rice, wheat flour, cooking oil, soy sauce and vinegar products. Of
these, 79.25 per cent were family businesses with fewer than 10 workers
each. Nearly 16 per cent of them were producing without a licence, and
quality control and safety inspections were void in 64 per cent of them.

Ji Zhanling, an official in charge of food hygiene in canteen cars under
the Shijiazhuang Railway Bureau, went further to cite what he called
"loopholes" in current food legislation.

He classified "problem" food and drinks into three kinds: those below the
hygiene standards, those below the proper nutrition standards and
dangerous types like adulterated liquors and wines.

"The existing laws, like the Food Hygiene Law and the Criminal Law, just
focus on whether food is clean and innocuous," he said. "Provisions on
nutrition values and safety, if any, are vague."

Shi Sizhen is a member of the National Committee of the Chinese People's
Political Consultative Conference, China's top political advisory body.

She submitted two proposals to this year's annual session of the CPPCC
National Committee in mid-March, demanding improvements in law
enforcement efforts to ensure food safety.

"In not a few cases," she noted, "a guy may make 1 million yuan
(US$120,900) by producing or marketing substandard or adulterated foods.

"When the wrongdoing is exposed, all the guy needs to do is to pay a fine
of a few thousand yuan or, in some cases, may have his business licence
revoked. The guy will remain free provided no deaths have been caused.
That's wrong."

Governmental role defined

Shi proposed that laws specify, in explicit language, the
responsibilities of governments for food oversight, obliging agencies to
monitor the entire process of food production and distribution, from
purchases of raw and processed materials to the delivery of finished products.

China's highest authorities have responded to such proposals by listing a
food safety law on the lawmaking agenda of the NPC. If all goes well, the
law should come out by the end of this year, covering the
responsibilities of food producers, establishment of food safety
monitoring systems, government supervision over food production and
distribution, as well as food quality control.

In a related development, people have expressed concern with genetically-
modified (GM) foods.

Also on the eve of this year's World Consumer Rights Day, a report was
released by Green Peace, a world non-profit organization for
environmental protection, noting that several types of food sold in
China's supermarkets contain GM ingredients, like the Ritz biscuits and
Campbell's soups.

Ma Tianjie, a Green Peace campaigner, was outraged at the double
standards of these companies, which are committed not to using
genetically modified ingredients in foods sold in Europe.

Ma notes that consumers are becoming more aware and cautious of such
foods. In a survey carried out in Beijing, Shanghai and Guangzhou in
2004, 62 per cent of the 600 respondents know about GM foods and 57 per
cent said they would not buy it - a big leap from 52 per cent and 40 per
cent in 2003, respectively.

A poll on the, one of China's portal websites, shows that nearly
82 per cent of the 6,937 respondents are against the promotion of
transgenic rice, which might be planted in large areas for commercial
purposes this year.

Some experts insist that transgenic foods are harmless, but Ma takes it
with a grain of salt. "Genetically modified food crops came into being
not long ago, and it is still early to say whether transgenic foods are
safe or harmful," he said.


European NGO Network on Genetic Engineering

Hartmut MEYER (Mr)
In den Steinäckern 13
D - 38116 Braunschweig

P: +49-531-5168746
F: +49-531-5168747
M: +49-162-1054755
E: coordination(*)
W: <>

   GENET-news mailing list